Opens in a new tab
Log in

Safeco Seeks 9.9% Homeowners Rate Cut in New Jersey

Safeco Insurance Company of America, part of Liberty Mutual Group, filed for a 9.9% average rate decrease on New Jersey homeowners renewals, citing better-than-expected loss trends.

The filing covers 7,559 homeowners policies and would reduce annual premium by approximately $2.12 million. Average premium for homeowners would fall from $2,847 to $2,566, a decrease of about $281. Across Safeco’s broader homeowners book, which also includes renters and condo policies, the overall impact would be an 8.4% decrease.

Safeco proposes lowering base rates for fire, hurricane, wind, hail and other components. In its actuarial memo, the insurer said its fitted one-year pure premium trend in New Jersey moved from +6.9% using data through the second quarter of 2025 to −15.3% using data through the second quarter of 2026. Pure premium measures expected loss costs per unit of exposure.

The proposed decrease follows a 3.9% rate increase that took effect on August 18, 2026. Safeco said the lower rates would stay in effect for at least six months and that it would submit another filing if it later reverses all or part of the adjustment.

Safeco submitted the filing on November 16 and requested effective dates of January 17, 2027, for new business and February 28, 2027, for renewals.

Get ERRRA in your inbox